A place to discuss real life ethical dilemmas to better your decision making process as an interpreter.
Wednesday, October 17, 2012
Blogging platform switch
Sunday, October 14, 2012
Are you late
-you laugh it off. He has no idea the situation you've set up already.
-you explain your situation at length including the ethical way you established your situation.
-you say something like 'actually, I'm early'
What are your other options?
Saturday, October 6, 2012
Please, Help Me.
You interpret question 1. She review the responses and signs, "2, right?" You don't catch your facial expression in time...
from then on you:
+look down after you interpret each question so she can't see your face
+put the paper in front of your face to hid all facial expressions
+go ahead and help her. She needs all the help she can get.
Monday, October 1, 2012
Send us your problems.
Friday, September 28, 2012
Interpreting in the dark
You are interpreting in the educational setting and your professor shows a long movie clip. Thankfully the movie is subtitled. But the professor holds running commentary throughout the entire clip. There isn't enough ambient light to interpret his commentary.
--you, do nothing. It's not related to the content anyway.
--interpret what you remember when the lights come back on.
--talk to the professor afterward.
What other options do you have?
Sunday, September 23, 2012
DeafMD.org survey
|
|
|
Saturday, September 22, 2012
I want this student out!
--Do you go along? Afterall, you are the second adult in the room.
--Do you decline? You service only the Deaf and Hard of Hearing Students.
--What are your options?
Monday, September 17, 2012
What you mised this week...
Saturday, September 15, 2012
You get option A
- it took so long to interpret Option A that the class had moved on.
- the student indicated they wanted the easier paper and he teacher said Option A was easier.
- the student understood Option A clearly and you didn't want to confuse him/her with explaining Option B
Do these factors justify your decision? Explain why or why not.
If these factors don't justify your decision, what are your options to fix this situation?
Wednesday, September 12, 2012
Read? Sure! When?
Do you:
--take it home and read it on your free time?
--read it before class?
--read it while you are the 'off' interpreter?
What are your responsibilities? What are your options?
Sunday, September 9, 2012
Weekly round up
Which is your child
Want to submit a dilemma?
Will you be in California this December? Following is information on what appears to be a fabulous and informative workshop.
Friday, September 7, 2012
Have a conflict?
These past few weeks have been light perhaps because of vacations and school starting. If you have a conflict or a decision you'd like to discuss, email the Ethical Terp at ethicalterp@gmail.com.
Tuesday, August 28, 2012
Which is your child?
You are at your son's football practice and because you can't leave practice, you are chasing your baby daughter around, trying to keep her out of trouble. At the end of practice you notice a group of parents signing with each other. This is your opportunity to introduce yourself.
Do you grab your baby, walk up to the group and introduce yourself saying your son is #12 and asking who their children are?
Do you introduce yourself as a working interpreter?
Do you walk the other direction because you don't want to get involved?
Do you feel awkward because you don't want to be the person who is like, "hi! I can sign too!"
Sunday, August 26, 2012
Weekly roundup
Re-interpretation
Eye-roll!!!
Workshops
Long Island RID is hosting "So to Speak... Interpreting Figurative Language" on September 8.
http://lirid.org/
Deaf-Blind Training is hosting a webinar starting Monday, September 4th on Common Eye Diseases in the Deaf Community.
If you are interested in listing your workshop, contact me at ethicalterp@gmail.com.
Happy Terping!
Friday, August 24, 2012
Re-interpretation
--what would you do next time to avoid the appearance of cheating?
--if you weren't done with your initial interpretation--perhaps the client needed a lot of expansion--how could you keep the instructor there?
--what are your options?
Monday, August 20, 2012
Eye roll!!
-what are your options in this situation?
-are you to tell your client what the instructor says when the client is not around?
Sunday, August 19, 2012
The Weekly Round Up
Can we be friends?
Can I see your pictures?
Look who is sleeping!
I have a problem
Saturday, August 18, 2012
Can we be friends?
Yes? You love her!
No? Doesn't matter. She is a client.
Friday, August 17, 2012
Can I see your pictures
Look who is sleeping
Wednesday, August 15, 2012
I have a problem
Do you
-chat. Or at least pay attention. If she gets in trouble that is in her.
-advise her to get back to work.
The boss walls by, looks at her and you and asks what is going on. What do you do?
Monday, August 13, 2012
Weekly Round Up
You're here! Want to work?
Let Me Show You
Are you looking for workshops?
Classifiers: Make English Tangible
Logical Reasoning for ASL Court Interpreters
Happy Terping!
Thursday, August 9, 2012
You're here! Great! Want to work?
Certainly its not unethical to accept work your agency offers you. But you feel like the agency held these jobs for people who put in face time.
Tuesday, August 7, 2012
Let me show you
Your student signs, "I can't read this. I don't get it.".
You ask, "have you ever seen a bitch tree before?"
Your student replies no. You look around and the teacher is busy with other students so you google on your smart phone: birch tree images. You show your student a few pictures of birch tree forests. Your student signs, "now I get it."
Were you right to search for clarifying images? Is that part of getting the message across or is it over stepping your role?
Wednesday, August 1, 2012
Can you find me a job?
--on one hand, you admire her resourcefulness. Of course you'll help.
--on the other hand, you've just met this person and only spoken with her for 15 minutes. How can you possibly help her find a job.
Sunday, July 29, 2012
Can you get the phone for me?
Is the a breach of confidentiality? She doesn't know who the consumer is, only time and general location of the job.
Saturday, July 21, 2012
A day in the life of a sign language interpreter
A Day in the Life of a Sign Language Interpreter
Enjoy
Sunday, July 15, 2012
Do you have a dilemma you want posted?
If you have an ethical dilemma or conflict, if you have a situation you want addressed and discussed, please email it to me at:
Ethicalterp@gmail.com
I'll put your situation into the line up.
Friday, July 13, 2012
Are you ready?
The agency replies, "depositions usually last a couple of hours."
Deposition=law. Your certified but not with a law specialty.
--you accept the job anyhow because it's all interpreting anyhow.
--you accept because although you aren't certified with law, you are qualified.
--you turn it down because your not qualified and kick yourself for being unprepared for an opportunity
--you turn it down but give the agency the name of another interpreter who is qualified and certified.
Wednesday, July 11, 2012
Um, I'd rather not say
--do you tell the journalist? After all, she wouldn't know any of your students.
--hell, no. The journalist will publish the research and then it'll be all over the world forever more that you work (worked, rather, because who wants an unethical interpreter) at Nice Gig Public School.
--how do you politely decline to give the info?
Monday, July 9, 2012
I heart you
So you tell them. After all, everyone enjoys a compliment.
--is telling a client you enjoyed working with them overstepping boundaries?
--is it simply polite?
Monday, July 2, 2012
My kid is calling
--you slip out and take the call. No one needs you anyhow.
--you ignore it. Anyone important would text anyhow.
--you see it's your child. You have to take it! (or do you?)
--what are your options?
Sweet honey in the rock
Does anyone know anything about Sweet Honey in the Rock?
sweet honey in the rock
Thursday, June 28, 2012
Shop til you drop
What you didn't factor in was the big bags you have to carry back to the office. The office where you happen to be working is a job training center for adults getting back on their feet and here you come in with bags full of shiny, new merchandise.
-it's your money and time, you should be able to shop when you like.
-it's not like your taking your merchandise out s d showing it to everyone.
-you should have waited until the end of the day.
Monday, June 25, 2012
Here's a job for you
Supporting a colleague or overstepping your boundaries?
Monday, June 18, 2012
What to do?
--leave? No interpreting happening anyway.
--play on your phone? Even though students aren't allowed electronic devices, you can play on yours, right?
--read? Traditionally an acceptable pastime for interpreters.
--other ideas?
Saturday, June 16, 2012
It's a heliocentric world out there
Thursday, June 14, 2012
What is your fee?
--if you can't take the job, should you even comment on the fee?
--is it ethical to say, "that is within the range we work", "that is low", or "that is high"?
--should the fee be different since the job wouldn't be through an agency?
Friday, June 8, 2012
A new NIC
From RID:
Building Value in Certification—A Status Report on the Enhanced NIC Interview and Performance Examination
By Clarence “Buck” Chaffee, President1 The Caviart Group, LLC
In July 2011, NAD and RID announced that the Boards of both organizations had approved a plan for developing the next generation of NIC Certification. The stated purpose of the changes was “to strengthen the effectiveness and increase the value of the NIC credential.” Since that announcement, a number of changes have been implemented: a national study (pre-Job/Task Analysis survey) of deaf, hard of hearing, and hearing consumers of interpreting services was conducted; the enhanced NIC Interview and Performance Examination was launched; and a new interview and performance examination scoring process was implemented.
So now, nearly a year after the enhancements were announced, the time has come to assess how the program is doing. Have these changes done what they were purported to do? Is the NIC credential more effective and more valuable as promised and, if so, how can anyone tell?
This interim report looks to address these questions and answer some of the additional questions that have surfaced in the community about the enhanced NIC Interview and Performance Examination. It will explain the logic and process used as well as the evidence to date as to the effectiveness of the changes.
To understand whether the enhanced NIC Interview and Performance Examination is an improvement, it is first important to understand what certification is and what it means for a certification program to be “effective and valuable.”
What is certification really about?
Certification is essentially a warranty provided by an organization that says that the people to whom the organization has issued a certificate have the knowledge and skills required to competently perform a given job at a given level. This means that anyone who engages or receives the services warranted from such certificants has the organization’s assurance that the certified person will be able to perform those services competently at the level in which they are certified.
This does not mean that all certificants are of equal ability. In fact, many will be able to perform additional services beyond those addressed in the certification, and some will be able to perform the job at a higher level. What the certification means is that all certificants can do the described job at least at the level of basic competency.
1 See Appendix A for information about The Caviart Group, LLC, and Mr. Chaffee’s credentials.
Read the full article here:
RID article on new tests
Tuesday, June 5, 2012
A day in the life of an interpreter
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XQhYWM8S94M&feature=youtube_gdata_player
The Ethical Terp curates this I formation for discussion purposes.
Friday, June 1, 2012
That was so sweet!!!
-are you right to share the compliment? Everyone likes to hear positive news, after all.
-suppose it was a complaint. Would you share then?
-what are you compromising by sharing information with other staff members. What do you gain?
-if you are a member of the educational team, does confidentiality apply to this situation?
Thursday, May 31, 2012
A few minutes in the life of a sign language interpreter
A Few Minutes In The Life Of A Sign Language Interpreter
Wednesday, May 30, 2012
But it's my break!
Do you
-guard your prep with the ferocity of a tiger?
-agree to give up your prep occasionally because you are being paid through the prep so you can be available?
-agree to interpret during your prep but request another time slot be set aside for your prep?
What are the benefits and downsides to each option?
Tuesday, May 22, 2012
Read this
--ok?
--turns out they love the book. Does that make it ok?
--suppose they don't give it back.
--what was your intention in loaning the book in the first place? (to build a relationship? Because the book and client happened to be in the same place at the same time? Because you encourage reading in general?)
--does your intention with lending the book make the act more un/ethical, less un/ethical, or it's just a simple book! Stop stressing already!!
Friday, May 18, 2012
A few minutes in the life of an interpreter
a few minutes in the life of a sign language interpreter.
Wednesday, May 16, 2012
I'm only trying to help
Friday, May 11, 2012
Substitute teacher=day off?
-is your job done as there will be no instruction?
-should you stay in the room, just in case?
-your bring paid to be present, so no question, you stay.
Thursday, May 10, 2012
Tuesday, May 8, 2012
Calculus chaos
You know your supposed to follow the teacher out of a classroom but when she left you were interpreting an explanation and was surprised by the teacher's sudden departure.
List everything wrong with this situation.
What are things you can do to prevent such a situation from reoccurring.
If you can't prevent this situation, what options do you have for dealing with it, for making ethical decisions while in this situation.
Sunday, May 6, 2012
A day in the life of an interpreter
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DR9rtDEMSgM&feature=youtube_gdata_player
a day in the life of an interpreter
Friday, May 4, 2012
Dance dance dance
Is it ok to ask your client if you can record them and share the recording with other people they know?
Suppose it's not a solo, but a group performance. Do you need to get the hearing people's permission too?
Tuesday, May 1, 2012
Terp Story: Job Cancellation
The Ethical Terp had no part in the creation of the video. This is curated for discussion purposes.
Monday, April 30, 2012
One drink, please
You are politely sipping your water when a guest at the function brings you a glass of white wine. You will be with this guest most of the evening and he was clearly uncomfortable with your teetotaling. You accept the wine with a gracious smile.
-Do you drink the glass and get another later in the evening?
-Do you keep the glass on hand so when people ask, you can say you have a drink?
-Do you explain you can't drink while working?
-Do you claim to practice a religion that forbids alcohol?
-What are your other options? What are the repercussions of each decision?
Friday, April 27, 2012
How about a poem to me?
Is that overstepping boundaries? Or is that relationship building?
Would it be different depending on the age if the client? (elementary vs high school vs college)
When would this kind if banter be acceptable or not?
Tuesday, April 24, 2012
Excuse me, please
How do you remedy the situation.
How do you prevent this from happening again?
Thursday, April 19, 2012
Keep your opinion out of it.
--what are your options to now erase your opinion from the conversation?
--suppose you hear, a week later, your client quit the program. Are you partly responsible?
Tuesday, April 17, 2012
No phones!
Monday, April 16, 2012
Enjoy this book
Is it appropriate to share books? No? What would it be ok to share? What would it not be ok to share!
Saturday, April 14, 2012
Educational team
Sure enough, the cheater had an answer written on her hand. She shows a number of her peers. Again, the teacher has no idea.
-what is your responsibility? She is hearing, not yours.
-but you are an adult in the room.
Tuesday, March 27, 2012
Can you relay a message?
You have seen her talk directly to your student before so you conclude she wasn't avoiding your student but just missed them before they left.
Although you consider
1.) telling her you'll have the student talk to her at the beginning of class tomorrow.
2.) saying when you see the student in class, you'll tell them
Instead you say sure. After all, you'll see them again in 15 minutes.
Right? Wrong? Options?
Thursday, March 22, 2012
Obama says thanks
Obama says thank you
This is a cool clip of the President responding in ASL.
Tuesday, March 20, 2012
What do we do, again?
Your students are working in a small group with hearing students. The professor takes 5 minutes explains the task at hand. He repeats the information again and again giving examples and explanations. You faithfully interpret it all. When the explanations are over and the professor says to start working, a hearing student says to you, "miss, what did the teacher want us to do?"
--keep in mind, if the hearing students don't understand the work, their low performance will bring down your student's grades.
--what are your options?
--how would the grade level (elementary, middle school or high school, college) impact your decision?
Thursday, March 15, 2012
They are just not that into you...
It's the last hour of a long school day. The teacher is reviewing past lessons--information your students know, and know signs for. Why, then, do they look at you as if you are from outer space?
You sign, "write this down on that paper. It will collected at the end of class.". Then you sign to them word-for-word what to write. They just stare. You sign it a different way. Nothing. You try again and wonder if zombies have eaten your kids' brains. You take another stab, this time asking questions about the subject material. This gets barely a nod of the head.
--are your kids ignoring you?
--is it just that it's the end of the day?
--or are you a lousy interpreter??
--regardless, what can be done?
Tuesday, March 13, 2012
Kids these days...
You interpret in high school and the current trend is for young men to pull their trousers down, exposing their boxers. Your student walks to the front of the class to hand in his work and the way back to his seat--your not looking! But can't help noticing -- he has a hole in his underwear. You look down, shake your head and when your student sits down you tell him to pull up his pants. He shrugs you off as all lame adults tell him the same thing.
Should you
--do nothing. After all, you don't want people to think you were looking.
--tell him about his wardrobe malfunction. After all, he wouldn't want other laughing at him.
--tell the school social worker to tell him. That way it doesn't come from you but he gets the info.
Monday, March 5, 2012
Keep up!!!
You are interpreting a high school English lesson. The teacher is teaching and reading quickly as she feels pressure to get her lesson in before her iPad timer rings. You are frantically keeping up but feel your doing a lousy job conveying information. You check in with your students asking a broad question about the topic. They answer correctly but still give puzzled faces back to you. You ask what's up and they say the teacher is going too fast. You ask if they want to review the info again.
--is this type of interaction appropriate? You do it all the time and see others do it too
--when the student ask for vocab clarification, is it ok to give them a definition or should you call the teacher over.
Friday, March 2, 2012
Tattle tale Terp
One of your mainstream high school students skipped one class to study for a test he was stressed about. You know this because he told you. You mention to his teacher--the one for the test he was studying for. She said that wasn't ok and she was going to talk to him.
--was it ok to tell the teacher? After all, you are part of the educational team.
--or was it a violation of confidentiality.
Thursday, February 16, 2012
I think I'll fail
The mandatory test for high school graduation are quickly approaching. While waiting with a student you ask, to make small talk, which tests he'll be taking. He signs, "I'm taking test X and I think I'll pass. I'm also taking test Y but I think I'll fail. The teacher is lazy and we never do anything!"
That teacher happens to be Deaf and works in the Deaf Ed office with you. There have been other complaints about this teacher.
Do you report back to your office supervisor that the students don't think they are well prepared for their mandatory tests?
Do you advise the student to tell the office supervisor?
Do you do nothing? After all, you are the interpreter, not a teacher or advisor.
Do you approach the teacher and tell them some of their students feel unprepared?
Friday, January 27, 2012
Too many hands in the pot
You have two students in the same history class. The students have different learning and speaking styles. She throws her hand In the air at any half-baked idea, (dont even go there. You judge too.) often giving valid input. He prefers to call the teacher over to have something explained privately. You are trying to interpret a conversation between him and the teacher while she is trying to give her input at the same time. You can't interpret it all. What do you do?
Wednesday, January 25, 2012
Don't laugh
You are interpreting a mandatory statewide test students must pass to graduate. Two girls taking the test keep giggling and engaging the you in conversation. They aren't cheating. They are just bored after sitting in a windowless room for 5 hours.
--what do you do?
Friday, January 20, 2012
What should I write?
It's the end of the semester and your client is thrilled to be close to done with this required art class. The professor required a two page, single spaced paper. Your client handed in a one page paper and the teacher said there is still time to add another page.
Your client signs to you, "what do you think I should write? I have no more ideas."
You sign back, "a few days ago your teacher said... . Maybe write something on that?"
-ok?
-no?
-should you have gone back to the professor with that question?
Thursday, January 19, 2012
No captions? We got an app for you
If the below link doesn't work, search "Subtitles" in the app store. The app the English teacher used was called "Subtitles" and created by Structure 6.
http://itunes.apple.com/us/app/subtitles/id358913522?mt=8&ls=1
Good luck!
Movie again?!?!!
At the end of the semester many teachers and professors show movies. Of course they have to relate the movie back to the coursework. Some teachers take this more seriously than others.
This teacher, whose classroom has no ambient light, comments multiple times during every scene. Comments are suggestions regarding information students can use in an essay. Or they are about test questions.
How are you to interpret, in the dark, the teacher's remarks?
(you are thanking your lucky stars the movie is captioned!)
Tuesday, January 17, 2012
Watch or read?
This is the first year the English teacher has had a Deaf student in class. She does a lot of read out louds which is difficult for you to interpret but not impossible. Teacher asks you one say which your students would prefer, you to interpreting the text or silent reading.
You ask the students what they prefer.
----
Friday, January 13, 2012
To read or not to read
In your college level English class the students are required to read novels. In order to interpret better, you decide also to read the novels. But you don't have a prep period during which to read. If you read, it would be done on your own time.
On one hand, you've been wanting to read these novels and now have a perfect excuse. On the other hand, shouldn't you be compensated for your prep work? After all, the prep works takes time from family/hobbies/other work.
Tuesday, January 10, 2012
Never Have Paris
Never Have Paris is accepting nonfiction stories of 1000 words or less for its upcoming zine. They are trying to create an all interpreter issue about experiences interpreters encounter. Have you been 'misinterpreted'? If so, write and submit your story!
never have paris
Want to be friends?
Your interpreting agency "friends" you on Facebook. You don't want the staff at the agency reading what you say about your kids or what you do on Saturday night. On the other hand, some of your peers mentioned they got work that the agency posted on Facebook.
Friday, January 6, 2012
Strike a pose
Wednesday, January 4, 2012
You go on ahead.
You and your team are leaving your job together and having a good conversation about the job. You've worked with this team before and get the feeling she tolerates you but isn't thrilled to work with you. Right before the elevator comes to take you down, she begs off. Apparently she needs to use the ladies room. You think she wants to avoid 7 minutes of conversation with you.