A place to discuss real life ethical dilemmas to better your decision making process as an interpreter.
Sunday, August 26, 2012
Friday, August 24, 2012
Re-interpretation
--what would you do next time to avoid the appearance of cheating?
--if you weren't done with your initial interpretation--perhaps the client needed a lot of expansion--how could you keep the instructor there?
--what are your options?
Wednesday, August 15, 2012
I have a problem
Do you
-chat. Or at least pay attention. If she gets in trouble that is in her.
-advise her to get back to work.
The boss walls by, looks at her and you and asks what is going on. What do you do?
Tuesday, August 7, 2012
Let me show you
Your student signs, "I can't read this. I don't get it.".
You ask, "have you ever seen a bitch tree before?"
Your student replies no. You look around and the teacher is busy with other students so you google on your smart phone: birch tree images. You show your student a few pictures of birch tree forests. Your student signs, "now I get it."
Were you right to search for clarifying images? Is that part of getting the message across or is it over stepping your role?
Monday, July 9, 2012
I heart you
So you tell them. After all, everyone enjoys a compliment.
--is telling a client you enjoyed working with them overstepping boundaries?
--is it simply polite?
Monday, July 2, 2012
My kid is calling
--you slip out and take the call. No one needs you anyhow.
--you ignore it. Anyone important would text anyhow.
--you see it's your child. You have to take it! (or do you?)
--what are your options?
Monday, June 18, 2012
What to do?
--leave? No interpreting happening anyway.
--play on your phone? Even though students aren't allowed electronic devices, you can play on yours, right?
--read? Traditionally an acceptable pastime for interpreters.
--other ideas?
Tuesday, May 22, 2012
Read this
--ok?
--turns out they love the book. Does that make it ok?
--suppose they don't give it back.
--what was your intention in loaning the book in the first place? (to build a relationship? Because the book and client happened to be in the same place at the same time? Because you encourage reading in general?)
--does your intention with lending the book make the act more un/ethical, less un/ethical, or it's just a simple book! Stop stressing already!!
Wednesday, May 16, 2012
I'm only trying to help
Friday, April 27, 2012
How about a poem to me?
Is that overstepping boundaries? Or is that relationship building?
Would it be different depending on the age if the client? (elementary vs high school vs college)
When would this kind if banter be acceptable or not?
Thursday, April 19, 2012
Keep your opinion out of it.
--what are your options to now erase your opinion from the conversation?
--suppose you hear, a week later, your client quit the program. Are you partly responsible?
Monday, April 16, 2012
Enjoy this book
Is it appropriate to share books? No? What would it be ok to share? What would it not be ok to share!
Saturday, April 14, 2012
Educational team
Sure enough, the cheater had an answer written on her hand. She shows a number of her peers. Again, the teacher has no idea.
-what is your responsibility? She is hearing, not yours.
-but you are an adult in the room.
Tuesday, March 27, 2012
Can you relay a message?
You have seen her talk directly to your student before so you conclude she wasn't avoiding your student but just missed them before they left.
Although you consider
1.) telling her you'll have the student talk to her at the beginning of class tomorrow.
2.) saying when you see the student in class, you'll tell them
Instead you say sure. After all, you'll see them again in 15 minutes.
Right? Wrong? Options?
Monday, April 25, 2011
So I've Heard
*Is it ethical to listen to stories about other interpreters rom a client?
*If the client tells you something unethical the interpreter did, what would you do? Do you give your client options for recourse? Defend your peer's actions? Listen and do nothing?
Wednesday, March 16, 2011
I hate my agency!
+Was it really appropriate to dis on your agency?
+What would have been another option?
+How can you be empathetic to your team while still remaining loyal to your agency?
Thursday, February 24, 2011
My Ex Sucks!
Do you:
+smile and nod. You don't want to get in the middle of it.
+readily take her side. She is offering you a ride home.
+tell her you'd rather not know. You may have to work with her ex one day.
+What are the short term ramifications of your decision?
+If you will want a ride from her again but don't want to be drug into her personal saga, how will you avoid the topic of her ex?
+How can you remain supportive but still distanced?
Monday, January 31, 2011
Can I leave early?
Would the following circumstances inform your decision:
1. The student never pays attention and you feel that is disrespectful.
2. They are doing group work and you know the student communicates well with his group.
3. You want to get some shopping done on your way home and would like to leave early.
4. You have nothing else to do and are paid to stay.
Consider the situation with the above variables. What would be the ethical options? What are the practical options. What would you do?
Saturday, January 15, 2011
OMG! I've gone viral on You Tube!!!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TJKA8us6k4k&feature=player_embedded#!
- What are the short term consequences?
- What are the long term consequences?
- If everyone did this, how would that effect the interpreting profession?
Wednesday, January 12, 2011
Coffee or Science?
You interpret in a high school on-going. During earth science you have a team as the material is difficult and the teacher lectures the entire period. Yet today—and about once a week—the students copy questions from the board and work on their own. Your team suggests, since neither of you are “working” you go out to buy your much needed coffee.
*Is it ok to leave during your scheduled interpreting time? Its possible you return the favor next week. And you’ll be back well before the next period.
*What are the professional consequences?
*What are the short and long term consequences?
*What pattern are you establishing for other interpreters in your high school?